Medicare should compensate physicians for the delivery of high-value, patient-centered care, with a payment system that accurately reflects the resources required by physicians to furnish services. Current Medicare physician payment policy fails to do this. It is largely based on fee-for-service (FFS) — where providers are paid based on the number and type of services they deliver, rewarding volume over value. Furthermore, the current system does not accurately price physician services, resulting in underinvestment in primary care and overpayment for specialty care, compensating many procedural services at much higher rates regardless of whether they meaningfully improve patient health.
Arnold Ventures supports re-orienting the health care system toward delivering higher quality, lower-cost care. One lever to achieve that aim is to accelerate the adoption of payment models that give providers greater flexibility to deliver the care their patients need, while holding them accountable for the total cost of care. This should encourage coordination between clinicians, engage patients to manage chronic conditions, and incentivize the utilization of high-value services. Another lever is to improve payment accuracy and rebalance spending towards primary care.
It is also true that Medicare’s current payment system fails to provide physicians with predictable payment levels, resulting in costly and temporary annual payment fixes. Correcting this is important, but any fix that fails to acknowledge Medicare’s unsustainable projected spending growth and address the underlying structural issues with physician payments would be deeply inadequate.
It is time for policymakers to establish a lasting framework for fiscally responsible Medicare physician payment reform. The recommendations below are where they should start.